Using the broiling pan in cooking is very exciting. Anyone can easily relate to this, even those without any cooking experience. The reason is that it’s easy to use and quick to cook dishes that include steaks, vegetables, and meats. You will love the final results that can look and taste like restaurant food provided you carefully followed recipe instructions if you are a newbie. To achieve a rewarding cooking experience, you might want to use the best broiler pan.
This cookware is a must-have in your collection if you want to explore and improve your cooking abilities because it is versatile enough to accommodate your cooking needs. However, finding one is no joke. The process can be quite overwhelming if you are buying one for the first time. That is why we’re here! In the following, find a buying guide along with the top 10 reviews of great broiler pans on the market.
Foodieandtours.com is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.
I. Our Top Picks for Broiler Pans
| Products & Features | Image & Price |
|---|---|
1. General Electric Large Broiler Pan and Rack |  |
2. Rachael Ray Cucina Nonstick Bakeware Set with Grips |  |
3. Pan 1604CR Quarter Sheet Pan |  |
4. Farberware 57026 Nonstick Roaster with Rack |  |
5. Granite Ware Broil and Grill Pan |  |
6. KITCHENATICS Roasting & Baking Sheet with Cooling Rack |  |
| 8. Norpro Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set |  |
| 10. Chicago Metallic Non-Stick Roast Pan with Non-Stick Rack |  |
| 7. Range Kleen Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan |  |
| 9. Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set |  |
- 12 Best Non-Stick Pans
- 5 Best Carbon Steel Pans
- 10 Best Ceramic Frying Pans
- 7 Best Roasting Pans
- 5 Best Medium and Large Saucepans
- 10 Best Bread Pans
II. What is a Broiler Pan Used For?
Cooking in a broiler pan is interesting. It can be used to cook different types of food that include poultry, meat, and vegetables. Using it, you can explore your creative side and prepare as many dishes as possible in terms of variety. These pans can also be used for baking or as bakeware to prepare various goodies ad treats.
Also called an oven roaster or a broiler roaster, you can use it in broiling foods that include steaks and roasts. Truly, it is a must-have in your kitchen if you’re looking for a versatile piece of kitchenware. You will not run out of options regarding the variety of foods for your loved ones and guests.
What is more interesting is that you can use it in making restaurant-quality steaks at home. So you can check out plenty of easy and simple steak recipes to enjoy. The construction of this piece of cookware is what makes it ideal for different dishes. It has a low-walled pan, and an upper cooking surface, also called a broiler plate lid. Its cooking surface has small holes that hold your food while it is cooking.
At the same time, the drippings are collected in the pan, preventing food from burning or flaring up. Nevertheless, the broiler pan is used for a wide range of cooking tasks. However, remember that the broiling method is not a set-and-forget type because it is pretty quick. Usually, food will be cooked in at most 12 minutes. You may also need to flip your food so that it can achieve even cooking.
III. Top 10 Best Broiler Pans
1. General Electric Large Broiler Pan and Rack
The large broiler pan and rack is a top-rated choice among nonstick with rack broiler pans. You might want to check out this General Electric broiler pan if you want long-lasting use and heavy-duty performance in your pan. You can use this item for various applications that include cooking vegetables, meat, and other foods. It is also suitable for oven or stove use, so there is no worry about the functionality of this product.
It is also affordable while not compromising the quality. In this case, you don’t need to worry about your pan being damaged after a couple of uses, provided you follow manufacturer instructions in maintenance and cleaning. Also, the General Electric WB48X10056 is dishwasher safe, adding to the ease of cleaning and maintenance of this item.
It is also a large pan that allows you to cook a large batch of food. But, when it comes to even results, you can count on it, especially with its venting slots, along with a serrated design that can ensure that.
Pros
- Dishwasher safe
- Large cooking surface
- Durable materials and long-lasting performance
- Even results
- It can be used for stove or oven
Cons
- Sharp edges
2. Rachael Ray Cucina Nonstick Bakeware Set with Grips
Rachael Ray bakeware and cookware is known in the industry for elegant and nicely designed products. This set, in particular, comes in a lovely latte brown color along with nice cranberry red handle grips.
For one, it is durable for its heavy-gauge steel construction. Furthermore, it is made even more durable for its rolled-rim edges. In addition, this item comes with a perforated insert for crisping. Therefore, it is best used for toasting and roasting.
Another thing to like about the nonstick pan is its high heat tolerance. You can use it in the oven for up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. And for added convenience, this cookware is with silicone handle grips that offer a comfortable hold even if you’re wearing potholders or mitts.
You can also rely on it for healthier cooking because it has a nonstick surface that reduces oil use. It is also perfect when it comes to cleaning up and food release. The pan is also easy to hand wash. This product also comes with a quality assurance guarantee for added peace of mind in your purchase.
Pros
- Includes a crisper pan
- Easy to clean
- Good heat tolerance
- Elegant and sleek design and color
- Heavy-gauge steel construction
Cons
- Nonstick wearing away over time
3. Pan 1604CR Quarter Sheet Pan
This product is made of quality materials. One of the things I loved about it is its American coating. It works by providing us with quick and easy food release. With it, you don’t need to worry about your goodies and food sticking to the surface. It is also easy to clean that you only need a sponge, soap, and hot water to do so.
You can also rely on this product when it comes to versatility. It is ideal for baking cookies, cooking vegetables, and roasting meats. With it, you can use a wide range of cooking techniques, giving you more value for your money.
It is also made of high-quality and durable aluminized and commercial-grade steel. You can look forward to long-term use when you choose this broiler pan. It is also notable that this item has a corrugated surface that further prevents the sticking of food. It also lets good airflow that speeds up cooking. You will also like that it can be relied on when it comes to baking different goods. When it comes to the cooling rack, it is one of the most reliable because it can promote uniform cooling. It is because of its six raised feet, which also offers stability.
Pros
- Versatile for cooking vegetables, cookies, cakes, and other dishes
- Corrugated surface for quick and easy airflow
- Uniform cooling
- BPA-free and PTFE- and PFOA-free
- Nonstick Americoat silicone coating
Cons
- It might warp at high temperatures like 350 degrees
4. Farberware 57026 Nonstick Roaster with Rack
Farberware is a reputable brand that you can trust when it comes to the heavy-duty performance of its products. One of its good offerings on the market is the Farberware 57026. It is with the solid performance features that you will love about the broiler pan.
The 11 x 11 inches grey broiler pan is perfect if you don’t need to cook a large batch of food. It is also with a sleek and elegant appearance that makes it a nice addition to your kitchen. I also liked that the baking pan with a rack is made of heavy-duty materials. It is with durable steel that can keep up with the heavy abuse and use in the kitchen. You will also appreciate that this item can resist warping, adding to its long-term performance.
You can also use its chrome-plated rack for raising meat to catch the drips that you can later use for sauces. It will also allow fat to drip away if you want healthier cooking. In addition, this pan is not hard to clean because it is nonstick.
You can count on its quick and easy food release, too. But, when it comes to maintenance, it is perfect for busy people because it cuts the cleaning time in half, allowing you to spend your time with loved ones other than spending a lot of it cleaning up the mess later.
Pros
- Affordable and quality item
- Heavy-duty steel roaster
- Easy to grip handles
- Quality assurance guarantee
- High heat tolerance up to 450 degrees F
Cons
- Smaller cooking surface
5. Granite Ware Broil and Grill Pan
Do you love grilling, baking, or broiling? If you do, you will love the 3pc set that allows you to do any of that. The Granite Ware set is one of the most functional and versatile sets I found on the market. It is what you need if you plan on using the pan other than just for broiling meats.
I would also like to note that this item is made in the USA for ensured quality and performance. Speaking of quality, the product is made of carbon steel core, allowing for fast cooking. With it, you can take advantage of energy efficiency while also looking forward to better cooking and browning.
Another thing to appreciate is its porcelain enamel surface that can deliver a nonstick performance. With it, you can cook with less oil and for the better health of your loved ones. Speaking of health, this item is without harmful chemicals and compounds like PTFE and PFOA. It is also dishwasher safe, adding to the ease of cleaning and maintenance.
Pros
- Versatile and functional for baking, roasting, and baking
- Carbon steel core durability
- Fast and even cooking
- Years of use performance
- Lovely porcelain enamel surface
Cons
- Warping issues
6. KITCHENATICS Roasting & Baking Sheet with Cooling Rack
The design is impressive. This item features a tight grid pattern that can prevent the sagging or falling of baked treats. It is unique that the manufacturer has considered it in the design. I would also like to recommend this item to those looking for cookware that does not contain harmful and toxic compounds and substances.
It is also versatile and functional that you can use it in preparing a wide range of desserts and dishes. You can also use it for cooking bacon and vegetables. It is also ideal for making crispy chicken wings under the broiler as well as baking different treats.
It is also a quality pan that you can use as a combo set or individually based on what you need it for, such as cooling cakes and cookies or broiling meats. This model also has tall legs that offer stability and provide enough airflow to food for fast cooking. You can also use it in cooling other food types. Get all these benefits and more if you would choose this pan.
Pros
- Versatile cookie pan tray with a wire rack
- Oven safe
- Heavy-duty materials
- Nontoxic construction
- A tight grid pattern prevents falling and sagging of baked goodies
Cons
- Sticking issues
7. Range Kleen Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan
The Range Kleen BP106X is what you need for perfect meals all the time. You can use it for baking, broiling, and a whole lot more. Therefore, it is one of the essential features to look for when comparing your options. This item is definitely a must-have for your kitchen collection because of its functionality to offer you the performance you want from cookware that can give you more versatility for different applications.
If you love broiling meats or baking lasagna and other foods, you can use this 2-piece set that you can count on for even cooking. I would also like to note that this model is made from top-notch porcelain on its base and steel grill. It is also one of those with the highest heat tolerance. It can withstand temperatures up to 1025 degrees Fahrenheit.
The Range Kleen BP106X is also good for grilling veggies, meats and fish. You might want to check it out if you love outdoor grilling with your loved ones.
Pros
- Functional for a wide range of uses
- Heavy-duty porcelain
- Dishwasher safe materials
- Healthier cooking for draining fat away
- Good for outdoor grilling
Cons
- Grate parts are hard to clean
8. Norpro Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set
Check out the Norpro Stainless Steel pan set if you are looking for reliable cookware that can offer you cooking convenience and comfort. One of the things to like about this pan is that it is made of strong and durable stainless steel. This material is also known to stand the test of time to resist corrosion and rusting.
It is also good to have a perforated top that drains the grease off for healthier cooking. With it, you can keep your family healthy while also serving them great food. You can also count on this or a pro-Stainless Steel set when it comes to cleaning and maintenance ease. It will not take much of your time to clean the mess later.
The item is also good for family size, two-person or individual servings. It is also ideal for boneless chicken, pieces of bread, veggies, loin meat cuts, and rib. If you want to take advantage of these features, you might want to check this broiler pan for yourself now.
Pros
- Quick grease draining for its perforated top
- Healthier cooking with reduced oil
- Durable and strong stainless steel
- Easy to maintain and clean
Cons
- It feels and looks flimsy
9. Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set
The 11 x 7-Inch pan set is one of the items not to miss when trying to compare your options. It is an ideal choice for a family or two-person servings and cooking a wide range of dishes.
You can also count on it if you want to cook healthy stuff for your loved ones. It is designed with a two-part pan that works effectively when draining grease and fat from fish and meat. With that said, you might also want to look at it if you are starting a healthy diet.
This item is also made of strong steel that can resist damage. With it, you can look forward to years of cooking with this pan set. In addition, you can also clean it easily because it is made with a nonstick surface that can reduce cleaning time. Finally, for added cleaning and maintenance convenience, it is also made dishwasher safe. But then, hand washing might still be better for the longevity of the pan.
Pros
- Durable and strong steel material
- Dishwasher safe
- Versatility and heavy-duty performance
- Nonstick coating for quick cleanup and easy food release
- Healthier cooking with reduced oil
Cons
- Thinner material
10. Chicago Metallic Non-Stick Roast Pan with Non-Stick Rack
Are you shopping around for a nonstick pan? You might want to check out the nonstick pan that we’re also featuring on this list for its solid performance. This item is one of the best for being nonstick that promotes healthy cooking and quick food release.
It also offers superior heat conduction that can cut the cooking time. Plus, you can count on it for even cooking and baking results all the time. You can also use it safely in the oven for having a high heat tolerance of up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit.
This item can also offer easy cleaning because it is dishwasher safe, but the manufacturer noted that hand washing is still the better option. Hand washing can prolong the product’s life. In addition, the pan is suitable for family and individual servings.
You can also rely on this pan for its versatility, which you can use for cooking meat, veggies, and fish, among other foods. Overall, it is a decent pick that you might consider for its heavy-duty performance, nonstick properties, and quality materials.
Pros
- Nonstick surface
- Daily roasting pan performance
- Even baking and cooking
- Oven safe up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
- Impressive heat conduction
Cons
- Not the most durable around
IV. What to Look for When Buying a Broiler Pan?
It can be quite tricky to find the right broiler pan for you without any idea of what matters. For this reason, you might want to compare before adding a product to the cart so that you can have more satisfaction in what you end up buying later. In the following, we’ve covered the most important aspects or features to look for when choosing a broiler pan. Let’s start.
Construction
It has to do with the heavy-duty performance and ability to withstand high oven heat. The materials and the properties will give you an idea of how long the product will last. The construction will also give you a glimpse of the overall design and strength of the material.
That is why it is one of the most important to check when comparing your options. You don’t want a broiling pan that will not last. It is a waste of money that you can avoid finding a pan that has durable materials. It also has to do with features like heat management and cooking healthily.
You will also find out if the material used is safe in cooking; if it is, you can be certain that you and your loved ones will be safe for using the cookware. In addition, it has to do with the nonstick properties of the pan. By now, you probably know why you have to look into the type of material of the pan.
For example, steel or carbon core is important for heat distribution and retention, while porcelain is good for nonstick properties. On the other hand, there is aluminum that is known for its attractive appearance.
Strength
As discussed earlier, the material can help you figure out how heavy-duty a particular product can be. It will also have to do with the heat retention of the material.
Maintenance and ease of cleaning
Everyone is busy and occupied by modern people’s things, so why bother to take a lot of time to clean the pan. You can choose those that you can clean without any hassles.
You should be looking into those pans that will not take much time to clean. One example that can offer that is a nonstick pan. It allows for quick cleaning and time saving on the maintenance aspect of using a broiler pan.
However, while some manufacturers claim that their pans are dishwasher safe, they might not tell you how it will affect the pan’s performance, especially in terms of longevity. According to the experts, you must always consider hand washing instead. After all, the process is simpler and will keep your pan in its top shape.
Functionality
You can opt for pans that have the basic broiling pan function if you love to cook meat only on it. In that case, you can limit your search to that kind of pan only, saving you plenty of time in the process. On the other hand, there are pans that you can use for cooking a wide range of dishes. For example, you can also use such in snacks. So when choosing one, you should also think about the cooking method or your purpose for buying the broiling pan.
Nevertheless, you must not compromise the quality of what you’re buying because it can give you more satisfaction in your purchase.
Size
You should also determine the size of the pan get. First, check for the dimensions of the pan. It is easy to transport; however, it is not ideal for cooking a large batch of food. That is why you need to determine the usual quantity of what you’re cooking in the broiler pan.
V. Conclusion
Hoping you learned something from the best broiler pan guide that outlines the things to look for when choosing what is for you. We also hope you can make a thorough comparison of the top picks in the category from the reviews. Each of them has its pros and cons and special qualities that you might want to look at when studying your options. Finally, you can make an informed decision by being equipped with the things to know about these pans.
Our team always strives hard to share useful information that you can use when selecting kitchenware. We’re looking forward to seeing you again here. Thanks for dropping by, and happy cooking!
